Pickering D-140S
One thousandth of an inch of diamond, five grams of tracking force, and the moment the long-playing record stopped sounding like a compromise.
Overview
The number that defines the Pickering D-140S is .001" - one thousandth of an inch, the radius of its diamond stylus, ground to track the fine-line grooves of the then-new Microgroove long-playing record. Pickering's own literature is blunt about why the radius mattered. A coarser point would not just distort the signal, it would fail to follow the groove at all, and so fail to "track." The D-140S was designed expressly for Microgroove, fine-line, slow-speed recordings, and the company said so plainly. It was priced to match: $60.00 list with the .001" diamond when it was announced, a serious sum for a phono pickup in that era.
The tracking spec is where the D-140S shows its age. Pickering rated it at five grams of stylus pressure, roughly one-sixth of an ounce, as the company's own copy put it. Next to later high-compliance pickups that is heavy, and nobody should expect to run this one at a gram and a half and get clean results. The design logic of the period was different. Pickering claimed that the five-gram force combined with a highly polished stylus held record wear to an absolute minimum and gave the diamond, in its words, unlimited life. Take the "unlimited" part with whatever salt you like. The pairing of that pressure with a polished whole-diamond point was the pitch.
Pickering made a point of the diamond itself. The jewels used in the D-140S were whole diamonds, not splints chipped from larger stones. The company drew that line deliberately, since a chipped splint could carry a compromised tip. For a stylus this fine, the literature warns, any wear would destroy the sharp radius the whole design depends on. A worn .001" point is no longer a .001" point.
Mounting was handled through what Pickering called the Keystone Clip Mounting, which allowed conversion from a standard cartridge to the D-140S in a matter of seconds. That is a small convenience by later standards. In a period when swapping pickups often meant fussing with screws and leads, a clip system was a real usability feature, and it fit how Pickering positioned the cartridge: as the practical upgrade path onto the new fine-groove format.
Reception, at least as Pickering chose to publicize it, was warm. The audio press of the late 1940s and early 1950s carried Pickering's claims for its fine-groove pickups alongside coverage of the new long-playing format, as seen in Audio (April 1949, p.33). The company circulated a testimonial from David Hall, director of repertoire for Mercury Classics, who reported that results from the D-140S were "100 percent satisfactory" and that he had been relieved of the distortion and tracking troubles previously encountered. That is a promotional quotation, not an independent lab measurement. Hall was a genuine authority on recordings, though, and Pickering led with his experience rather than a spec sheet. The same material claims a good signal-to-noise ratio and the widest frequency range of commercial reproducers. That is marketing copy, not a measured verdict.
Pickering was careful to fence the D-140S off from its stablemates. The same period literature also promoted the R-150, a home-oriented cartridge for conventional phonographs, and warned in capital letters that the R-150 was not to be used with Microgroove records. Long-playing discs required the D-140S with its diamond stylus, or the S-140S with a sapphire. That pairing helps sort out which Pickering cartridge belongs on which turntable. The D-140S is the Microgroove tool, and it should not be pressed into service on 78s or standard-groove transcription discs any more than the R-150 should be used on an LP.
By the early 1950s the cartridge had become a fixture of the secondhand and surplus market as well as the dealer shelf. Classified advertisements in the audio press listed the D-140S at discounted prices. One 1952 ad offered new, sealed-box examples at $28.50, well under the original list. Buyers were also hunting used ones, with at least one 1955 classified offering to pay $15 for a D-140S in good condition. Against the original $60 list, that makes it a working cartridge that people bought, used, and traded, not an instant heirloom.
The D-140S is not a forgiving modern daily driver. The five-gram tracking force, the fixed .001" diamond, and the whole-diamond construction all point to a design optimized for a specific groove geometry and a specific era of playback. A worn or damaged stylus cannot simply be ignored, because the entire premise of the cartridge is that sharp radius. The Keystone clip mounting, while convenient in its day, also means the cartridge is happiest in a period-appropriate arm.
eBay Listings
As an eBay Partner, we earn from qualifying purchases. This helps support our independent vintage technology research.